To flip a class is
like to shuffle the order of teaching a course. The traditional order: the
teacher teaches in class, students go back home and do homework and the teacher
assesses students’ understandings and skills from students’ assignments and classroom
performances. However, the flipped class order puts the homework-doing part
ahead of the in-classroom teaching. The problem would be: how could students be
able to finish the assignments before the teacher even teaches them the
knowledge? The key point here is that the teacher must prepare students with
sufficient and effective teaching materials for students to learn from at home.
Therefore, the order of a flipped class is: students work at home (with
teaching materials and home assignments), students work with peers and the
teacher in class, and students continue to work after class. (references: Flipping Your EL Classroom: A Primer and Three Reasons to Flip Your Classroom
I haven’t flipped
a class yet. But here are some concerns of mine:
1. How can we as
teachers make sure that materials (video, audio and texts) we create for
students to work at home before class are guiding them in the right way? Unlike
teaching in class when we can see students’ responses while teaching, teaching
a flipped class may cause extra time and energy at students’ costs if they couldn't
make the most use of the materials if the materials are not designed
to-the-point. The students may spend lots of time trying to figure out
something on their own, only to find that they are thinking in the wrong way
when they are communicating with the teacher in class. It is possible because
for some knowledge, it could be hard to be explained in materials rather than
teacher’s in-person instruction. Flipping a class relies hugely on the quality
of materials given by the teacher, yet the materials are hard to be designed
and aligned through a period of time.
2. Since students
work on their own at home, it is hard for the teacher to supervise the process.
If in a large class, it is hard for the teacher to assess the learning outcome
of each student in class. If a student doesn't study at home and the teacher
fails to assess that in class, the teacher would lose the control of tracking
the learning of the student. How can we make sure that all students would go
through all materials and study on their own at home?
3. How does the
teacher assess the outcomes of students’ learning at home in class observations
and after-class assignments?
4. Time is a big
concern, too. The teacher may have to commit a lot of time to preparing the
materials, not only keeping in mind the learning habits of his/her students but
also taking into account the different proficiency levels of the students. Is
there a rubric for designing materials for a flipped class?
I hope I can
answer these questions after I have flipped a lesion myself with TED.
You have posed excellent concerns about flipping a class. Regarding whether the teaching materials created for introduction of material work, I think that only trial and error will proves their effectiveness. Regarding a student not doing the assigned material, the teacher could give a short quiz at the beginning of the class. Those who understood the material could do further practice materials and those who did poorly on the quiz could be "retaught" by the teacher or by some other method. (This problem is similar to students not doing traditional homework). Regarding time, once a teacher has chosen or developed good lessons and seen if they are effective, the teacher can reuse them. Regarding a rubric, I think it would be hard to develop given the wide variety of assignments possible, but I may just not be aware of such rubrics.
ReplyDelete